Dallas-Fort Worth Real Estate Investor Club

Questions about lease-to-purchase transaction

  • 24 Jun 2013 10:17 PM
    Message # 1326221

    During the process of fixing up my former home to sell, someone looking for a house in the area drove by and “fell in love” with it.  He is very interested in the house, but cannot afford to buy it outright at this time (recently moved to the area, insufficient down payment for a conventional mortgage, other credit problems).  He is currently renting a home about the same size as mine, for what I would consider a reasonable rent on my house, so he can manage that payment.  However I do not want to rent it, i.e. I do not want to be a landlord.  That leaves me two options:  owner financing and lease-to-purchase, either of which he is amenable to.  I am not in a position to afford to offer owner financing, and I really don’t want that hassle or risk. 

    So I am in the early stages of investing lease-to-purchase conditions.  I would welcome the opinions, suggestions, and advice of those with experience in this area.  Ideally I would like to sell the house outright, but the prospect of immediate and steady income is appealing; I don’t know whether the house would sell quickly or sit on the market for months or longer.  In my understanding of this transaction, the seller’s risks are diminished by an option fee and rental premiums, there are fairly strict conditions on violating the terms of the contract, and the buyer is often required to maintain the house as if he owns it including handling many/most repairs, alleviating the seller of the “landlord” responsibility.  Additionally, the buyer has more of a stake in maintaining the home’s condition if he plans to purchase it in the future (I did SIGNIFICANT repairs and renovations on the house recently and do not want it to fall into disrepair as houses can in rental situations). 

    Some of my questions include:

    What length of contract is ideal/acceptable?  I don’t want to be in this for too long, but I know it will take some time for him to establish or rebuild his credit.  At the end of the term, he will be required to secure funding on his own; I will not be the lender.

    What percentage of the sale is typical for option fees?  I am also unclear about the refundability of this fee, i.e. whether it is entirely forfeited to the seller if the buyer decides not to purchase the house at the term of the contract or if some portion goes back to the buyer.

    What amount is typically charged for rental premiums (fixed amount or % of rent)?  Is this added onto the agreed-upon rent?

    Is the contract subject to similar conditions as a sale, such as home inspection?  Who is responsible for property taxes?

    What are the tax implications for me for this type of transaction?

    Is this a reasonable consideration at this time, in this market?  I can “afford” to keep the house, and if the buyer cannot meet the standards for qualification, I am prepared to list it, but it would be nice to move in the direction of selling it, even if slowly.  (It’s in a 20-year old single-builder subdivision in north Arlington near 360 and the Ballpark.)

    If I proceed in this direction, can someone recommend a real estate attorney with expertise in this area?

    There are many questions to be answered, both for my own information and about the potential buyer, but he is pushing for a relatively quick decision so he doesn’t have to renew the rental he is currently in.  We have already loosely discussed a sales price.  Please feel free to be totally honest about this prospect.  I have received some excellent advice from club members in the past and I value your knowledge and input.  Thank you in advance for your kind consideration.

    Mary Beth Vono

  • 25 Jun 2013 9:10 AM
    Reply # 1326561 on 1326221
    Robin Carriger (Administrator)

    Hi Mary Beth, I'm in a hurry this morning, so I apologize in advance for not giving you a more detailed answer on this.  First of all, I commend you for asking such good questions.  Some people might just assume it's OK and get themselves into a jam.  I'm not an attorney, and I'm not offering legal advice, but I've listened to attorneys on this topic.  The short answer is, don't sell your house using a lease with an option to buy.  It's not illegal, and many people do lease-option transactions in Texas, but it's definitely onerous for the seller if you do it correctly.  If you really want to do it, I recommend you consult a real estate attorney.  I believe you'll get more responses on this thread, but, if you don't and would like to call me to chat about this, please feel free to do so.  I'm at 817-300-1132.  Thanks, Robin

  • 26 Jun 2013 6:21 AM
    Reply # 1327318 on 1326221

    Mary Beth,

    I agree with Robin.  Speak with an attorney or I'd be happy to speak with you and offer a couple alternatives.

    Tim

    817-599-8058

     

    Last modified: 27 Jun 2013 7:36 AM | Robin Carriger (Administrator)
  • 27 Jun 2013 6:26 PM
    Reply # 1328753 on 1326221
    Deleted user
    There is another resource for you outside the club by the name of John Jackson. John has based his real estate investment company  on assignment of lease option, matching sellers and buyers. His company is LeasingToBuy. You can ask me more about him off the board.

  • 27 Jun 2013 10:58 PM
    Reply # 1328854 on 1326221
    Thank you all for the advice and suggestions.  I contacted one real estate attorney but he does not prepare lease/option contracts; I'm waiting to hear back from another.  I found the Leasing to Buy website and I will contact John Jackson for some information as well.  That looks like a very promising lead.  Thanks again!
  • 28 Jun 2013 9:14 AM
    Reply # 1329070 on 1326221
    Deleted user
    a) sell it to someone else
    b) don't be afraid to rent it. being a landlord is not that bad. and the tax benefits of renting are significant.
    c) I would give serious pause before lease-purchasing. I have not seen enough benefit for the investor to justify that route to me.

    Respectfully,

    Kyle McCaw
    Last modified: 29 Jun 2013 6:31 AM | Robin Carriger (Administrator)
Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software